The New Troy Grace Brethren Church in New Troy was began in 1940, with Rev. Russell Williams as the first pastor. The church was affiliated with the Fellowship of Grace Brethren Churches. In 1991, the church separated from the FGBC and formed the CGBCI – Conservative Grace Brethren Churches International. We are still affiliated with the CGBC as of this date.

Pastor Bob Mensinger has served as Pastor here since December of 2016. He was ordained into the ministry on July 20, 2019 at his home church in New Troy. Rev. Mensinger was honored to have 11 fellow pastors and 3 elders lay hands on him for his ordination ceremony. Two of the fellow pastors were his brothers, Dr. Edward Mensinger, and Rev. Wayne Mensinger, also ordained.